NOTICE: ALL ORDERS OVER $100 GET A FREE RANDOM B-GRADE PIN. FREE SHIPPING FOR USA ORDERS OVER $100

New Arrivals

Filter by
Availability
Availability
35 results
Sort by Featured
Sort by

35 products

Quick buy
Gumbo the Gator squeaky keychain plush [PRE-ORDER SHIPS LATE NOVEMBER/EARLY DECEMBER]
PondHQ
$28.00
Quick buy
Cowboy Fred Squeaky Keychain Plush [PRE-ORDER SHIPS LATE NOVEMBER/EARLY DECEMBER]
PondHQ
$28.00
Chad the CATerpillar - PondHQ
Quick buy
Chad the CATerpillar [PRE-ORDER SHIPS LATE NOVEMBER/EARLY DECEMBER]
PondHQ
$72.00

8 reviews
Dave the Angy Desert Rain Frog - PondHQ
Quick buy
Dave the Angy Desert Rain Frog [PRE-ORDER SHIPS LATE NOVEMBER/EARLY DECEMBER]
PondHQ
From $26.00

29 reviews
Frank the Fat Snake - PondHQ
Quick buy
Frank the Fat Snake [PRE-ORDER SHIPS LATE NOVEMBER/EARLY DECEMBER]
PondHQ
$46.00

1 review
Quick buy
Molly the Moth [PRE-ORDER SHIPS LATE NOVEMBER/EARLY DECEMBER]
PondHQ
$32.00

5 reviews
Quick buy
Oh no I died print
PondHQ
$15.00
Quick buy
Mage hand print
PondHQ
$15.00
Quick buy
Shrimp fried rice print
PondHQ
$15.00
Quick buy
I'll be there in 5 minutes print
PondHQ
$15.00
Quick buy
win condition print
PondHQ
$15.00
Quick buy
Pumpkin frogs print
PondHQ
$15.00
Quick buy
Family of Duckies print
PondHQ
$15.00
Quick buy
Sparrow dragon print
PondHQ
$15.00
Quick buy
Hummingbird dragon print
PondHQ
$15.00
Quick buy
None of my work is done but I am sticker
PondHQ
$6.00
Quick buy
Woke up and chose violence sticker
PondHQ
$6.00
Quick buy
Hocus pocus I can't focus sticker
PondHQ
$6.00
Quick buy
I loaf you bready much sticker
PondHQ
$6.00
Quick buy
Don't make me beet you sticker
PondHQ
$6.00
Quick buy
Couch Potato Sticker
PondHQ
$6.00
Quick buy
A cats journey: Forest Land // Custom foil cards for Magic the Gathering
PondHQ
From $8.00
Quick buy
A cats journey: Swamp Land // Custom foil cards for Magic the Gathering
PondHQ
From $8.00
Quick buy
A cats journey: Island Land // Custom foil cards for Magic the Gathering
PondHQ
From $8.00
Quick buy
A cats journey: Mountain Land // Custom foil cards for Magic the Gathering
PondHQ
From $8.00
Quick buy
A cats journey: Plains Land // Custom foil cards for Magic the Gathering
PondHQ
From $8.00
Quick buy
Squirrel token // Custom foil cards for Magic the Gathering
PondHQ
From $8.00
Quick buy
Squirrel food token // Custom foil cards for Magic the Gathering
PondHQ
From $8.00
Quick buy
Avogato food token // Custom foil cards for Magic the Gathering
PondHQ
From $8.00
Quick buy
The cutest glizzy food token // Custom foil cards for Magic the Gathering
PondHQ
From $8.00
Quick buy
Wizard frog token // Custom foil cards for Magic the Gathering
PondHQ
From $8.00
Quick buy
A cats journey: Full Set // Custom foil cards for Magic the Gathering
PondHQ
$34.00
Quick buy
Nuts for Squirrels // Custom foil cards for Magic the Gathering
PondHQ
$13.00
Quick buy
Food for the whole table // Custom foil cards for Magic the Gathering
PondHQ
$19.00
Quick buy
THE WHOLE DROP PLEASE // Custom foil cards for Magic the Gathering
PondHQ
$67.00

Let customers speak for us

from 543 reviews
Perfect Chaos

I absolutely adore the sticker, love how it looks on my water bottle my one regret it’s not buying more when I was at comic con.

Isabella E
1 sticker

Soft cute detailed

Cg
Karl the Koi Fish
Karl the Koi Fish
Good Freg

Sent to friends as gift for the little one. Thought it was snail. Unfurled into long freg. Untamed happiness.

Anonymous
Long Fred Plush
Long Fred Plush

Soft and adorable!

L.W.
Karl the Koi Fish
Karl the Koi Fish
Absolutely adorable!!!

One of my viewers on my twitch got me three pins, and they’re all so cute and great quality!!!

xxitspenelope
Gun Frog Pin
Gun Frog Pin
Perfection

He is Long Fred. He is perfection.

D.H.
Long Fred Plush
Long Fred Plush

Amazing!!! Such a soft and squishy little guy! I didn’t realize it had a squeaker in it so i was delightfully surprised! 10/10 will be buying the other cuties before they’re all gone!!

T.I.
Colorful Frogs [RETIRING]
Colorful Frogs [RETIRING]
Precious squishy bean

Perfectly huggable, squishable, and throwable at my friends.

RHW
Bloom the Cat Plushie [LIMITED EDITION] [RETIRING]
Bloom the Cat Plushie [LIMITED EDITION] [RETIRING]

SO CUTE!!! and very soft. Took a good amount of shakes for the flowers to come off!!! So they're pretty stable. Perfect snuggle buddy.

D.P.
Bloom the Cat Plushie [LIMITED EDITION] [RETIRING]
Bloom the Cat Plushie [LIMITED EDITION] [RETIRING]

So adorable!

Lizbeth
Karl the Koi Fish
Karl the Koi Fish
Wonderful! Little blubs!

Got my angry Dave and a Bloom for the Mrs.
Don't think I've ever laughed so hard as I did reading the tag that came with Dave describing why he was B-Grade. Two words. "Scrungle Face"
Whoever wrote that is a person after my own heart haha!
Still great quality and so cute!
Apparently bloom has uneven ears but I wouldn't have noticed :)

Quinn Cullison
B-Grade Plush Gacha
B-Grade Plush Gacha
Adorable!

So cute!

Kaye
Scuba Frog Keychain
Scuba Frog Keychain
Perfect

An absolute perfect, friend-shaped lil guy. Soft and adorable. Can’t wait to gift him to my entomologist bff 🩷

Kit
Steve the Stag Beetle
Steve the Stag Beetle
beetlr

:)

Customer
Steve the Stag Beetle
Steve the Stag Beetle
Cuddle buddy, back pillow, whatever!

I bought Long Fred to be a cute buffer pillow between my king size mattress and bedframe. He works! And he's so cute peeking out of the pillows. Lately I've been using Long Fred as a cuddle plush when I'm facing one way and a back pillow when facing the other way. Very comfy, very endearing, very versatile, 10/10.

Ashley S.
Long Fred Plush
Long Fred Plush
516
40